(Bok-Hyun Oh)
1
(Chung-Il Ma)
1
(Ji-Yeon Kwak)
2
(Heon Kong)
3
(Sang-Jin Lee)
13*
Copyright © 2021 The Korean Institute of Metals and Materials
Key words(Korean)
metal-ceramic composite, thermal conductivity, thermal expansion coefficient, polymer solution method, hot press sintering
1. Introduction
The amount of heat generated by electronic devices increases as the performance and
integration of the electric and electronic devices continues to increase. Furthermore,
the heat generated in the material causes the deterioration of functions and malfunctions
in peripheral devices and degrades the durability of equipment. For these reasons,
a great deal of research has been conducted on technology to control the generated
heat [1-5]. In general, the heat generated from an electronic device is controlled using a
heat sink. The heat dissipation material used for this purpose has high thermal conductivity
and a thermal expansion coefficient suitable for electronic devices such as semiconductors
and LEDs. In the case of a heat dissipation material made of a single metal, there
is an advantage of having excellent thermal conductivity. However, failures may be
caused by residual stresses due to differences in the coefficient of thermal expansion
from electronic components such as a semiconductor substrate, because the single metal
has a relatively high coefficient of thermal expansion. In order to solve this problem,
studies have been actively conducted on the metal base-ceramic filler composite materials
manufactured using a metal having high thermal conductivity as a matrix and a ceramic
having low thermal expansion coefficient as a filler [6-8]. To manufacture such composite materials, a mechanical mixing method using solid
powder is applied [9-12]. For example, according to a study by J. Tian [9], a Cu-AlN composite having a thermal conductivity of 235 W/m·K and a thermal expansion
coefficient of 12.6 × 10-6/°C was fabricated by mixing AlN of 40 vol% (including 6 wt% Y2O3) with Cu and sintering by a hot pressing method. According to another study [10], when manufacturing a mechanical alloy of Cu-AlN by attrition milling, the behavior
of the thermal expansion coefficient that approaches Turner’s rule was investigated.
Here, when the content of Cu exceeded 60 vol%, it was found that the theoretical rule
of the mixture was almost identical to the calculated value. In this study, a thermal
conductivity of less than 100 W/m·K was observed due to pores in the Cu matrix. These
methods have the disadvantage of not satisfying the thermal properties, especially
thermal conductivity, due to the difficulty of homogeneous mixing and the presence
of pores with local aggregation and a heterogeneous microstructure. To solve these
problems, it is necessary to apply liquid base mixing and sintering processes to enhance
the densification of the composite.
In the present study, Cu which has excellent thermal conductivity among metal materials
was used as the base-matrix material, and AlN and SiC which have relatively high thermal
conductivity and low thermal expansion coefficient, were selected as the filler materials
to make the metal-ceramic composite. The composite was designed to maintain high thermal
conductivity and to reduce the thermal expansion coefficient of the Cu matrix for
application as a high performance heat dissipation material. A new method was employed,
in which a ceramic powder filler and a Cu sol were mixed to form a slurry-type precursor.
In particular, a polymer solution method was applied for a homogeneous Cu sol. The
polymer solution synthesis method is one of the solgel methods. This is a powder synthesis
method in which the physical action of steric entrapment between cations dissolved
in a solvent and polyvinyl alcohol causes dispersion of the cations to obtain precursors
that are chemically homogeneous and stable [11-15]. This process has the advantage that the particle size of the produced powder can
be controlled to prepare a very fine powder through an appropriate milling process,
and thus the powder compact has excellent sintering properties [16-18]. In this study, the dried and calcined composite powders prepared by the solid-liquid
hybrid method employing the polymer solution method were hot pressed to obtain a dense
metal matrix-ceramic filler composite. The microstructure and thermal properties of
the composite were also examined.
2. Experimental Procedure
Cupric nitrate hydrate (Cu(NO3)2·2.5H2O, 98% purity, Sigma-Aldrich, Co., USA) was used as a precursor for Cu as the matrix
material. AlN powder (99% purity, H type, Tokuyama, Japan) and SiC powder (#10000,
99% purity, Dongkwang Micron Co., Ltd., Korea) were used for the ceramic powder added
as a filler. The microstructure of each powder is shown in Fig 1. It is shown that AlN has a spherical particle size of 0.2 μm, and the SiC has a
wide particle size distribution from 0.1~0.5 μm.
The cupric nitrate hydrate powder was dissolved in ethyl acetate (99%, Daejung Chemicals
& Metals Co., Ltd., Korea), and the solid AlN or SiC powders were added to the mass
ratio contents of the base matrix and filler, respectively. In order to maximize the
dispersion of the ceramic filler, PVB (polyvinyl butyral, Sigma-Aldrich, molecular
weight : 50,000~80,000) was mixed by adding 5 wt% solution in a mass ratio. The slurry
was dried while stirring on a hot plate, and then the obtained gel-type precursor
was completely dried in a dry oven for 24 hours. As AlN decomposes upon reaction with
water, the ethyl acetate was used as a solvent in this study.
The completely dried precursors were calcined in a reducing atmosphere (4% H2 - Ar gas) at 500 °C, for 1 hour at a heating rate of 3 °C per minute to remove organic
materials. The flow rate of the gas was set at 70 NmL/min in consideration of the
chamber size (500cc) of the tube furnace. The calcined powders were uniaxially pressed
at 10 MPa, and then sintered at 990 °C for 1 hour under a reducing atmosphere (4%
H2 - Ar gas) at a heating rate of 3 °C per minute. In addition, hot pressing was performed
to obtain a more densified sintered body. Finally, pressure sintering was conducted
with the sample previously sintered (without pressure), at 900 °C for 1 hour under
a reducing atmosphere and a pressure of 20 MPa.
In order to examine the crystallization behavior of the prepared precursor, an X-ray
diffractometer (XRD, X'pert-pro MPD, PAN analytical, Netherlands) was used. The analysis
was conducted using a Cu-Kα characteristic wavelength with a scan speed of 4°/min.
The microstructures of the synthesized precursor and the metal base composition were
observed using a field emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM: JSM-7100F. JEOL,
Japan). The sample was fixed using a carbon tape in an aluminum holder and coated
with Au-Pd via sputtering to observe the microstructure. In order to measure the thermal
conductivity of the composite, a laser flash apparatus (LFA: LFA447 Nanoflash. NETZSCH,
Germany) with a laser flash was used. The specimen was heated by laser at a heating
rate of 10 °C per minute from room temperature to 300 °C, and the time it took for
heat to be transferred to the opposite side was measured with an infrared sensor.
The thermal expansion coefficient of the composite was examined using a thermo mechanical
analyzer (TMA: TMA402F1 Hyperion. NETZSCH, Germany), and was measured from room temperature
to 600C. The relative density of the composites was calculated based on the theoretical
density (5.88 g/cm3 and 5.78 g/cm3 of Cu-30% AlN and Cu-30% SiC filler) obtained from the rule of mixture.
3. Results and Discussion
Fig 2 shows the microstructure of the composite powder obtained after calcination of the
Cu-AlN and Cu-SiC precursor powders in a reducing atmosphere. The ceramic filler powder
and the fine metal Cu powder were mixed without relatively large agglomeration. It
was observed that after all of the PVB binder was degassed the microstructure showed
a porous structure, and very fine Cu particles were partially aggregated around the
filler powder. According to a previous study by S. J. Lee [19,20], ultrafine Cu powder with a primary particle size of 10 nm was synthesized at 300
°C through the PVA polymer solution method. This study speculated that Cu powder close
to a nano scale was synthesized by the polymer solution method.
Fig 3 shows the results of an X-ray diffraction analysis of each sample after sintering
the Cu-AlN and Cu-SiC composite powders prepared using the PVB polymer solution synthesis
method. No second phase by the reaction between the Cu and the ceramic filler was
observed, and only the peaks of the Cu and the ceramic filler were observed. Although
the presence of reactants that can affect the thermal conductivity is excluded, the
effect of pores in the sintered body and defects in the lattice will be important
considerations for thermal conductivity and thermal expansion coefficient. According
to a study by G. A. Slack [21], in the case of AlN, when exposed to oxygen in the atmohere, Al2O3 is formed on the surface of the AlN particles, and upon sintering, oxygen is introduced
into the AlN lattice to form aluminum voids. In ceramics these vacancies scatter thermal
energy via the heat transfer mechanism of phonon conduction and cause a decrease in
thermal conductivity. It is therefore important to remove oxygen from the lattice.
In this experiment, when calcination and sintering were performed to manufacture the
composite, the atmosphere was controlled by using high-purity reducing gases to prevent
reactions with oxygen in the atmosphere.
Fig 4 shows the surface microstructure of the pressureless sintered body of Cu-AlN and
Cu-SiC composite powders. It was found that as the amount of AlN filler increased,
the densification of Cu interfered with the increase in pores in the sintered body.
When 30 wt% of SiC was added as a filler, the densification of the Cu matrix improved
more than that observed with the use of AlN, but pores in were still observed the
sintered body. Since the pores in the manufactured composite material significantly
influence thermal conductivity, it is important to minimize them as much as possible.
Hot press sintering was performed to reduce the pores in the composite. Fig 5 shows the surface microstructure of the specimen after hot press sintering by adding
30 wt% of AlN or SiC filler to the Cu matrix. Compared to the composite prepared by
pressureless sintering, the pores were notably reduced, and hence a relatively dense
Cu composite microstructure was observed. The measured densities of the hot-pressed
Cu-30% AlN and Cu-30% SiC composite were 5.67 g/cm3 (96.4% relative density) and 5.51 g/cm3 (95.3% relative density), respectively. The shape of the ceramic filler was clearly
observed and a few filler particles were agglomerated (circle marks). According to
previous experiments [22], such a compact structure could not be obtained by hot press sintering when using
a commercial Cu powder, which has a larger and non-uniform particle size compared
with the fine Cu powder synthesized in the liquid phase. More specifically, in the
composite with the ceramic filler, since the densification of the Cu matrix is hindered
by the influence of the filler, the second phase might be a critical variable for
densification.
Fig 6 shows an enlarged image of the microstructure at the interface between the Cu matrix
and the ceramic filler. It was confirmed that the interface between the Cu matrix
and the filler is tightly bonded without reactants. Most of the pores were observed
in the area where the ceramic filler had agglomerated. While the AlN has spherical-shaped
particles with a narrower particle size distribution, while SiC had angular-shaped
particles with a 0.1~0.5 μm wide particle size distribution. The SiC particles were
aggregated or heterogeneously mixed with Cu powder around the sharpened polygonal
particles, and some pores were generated. Fig 7 shows the results of the EDS mapping analysis of the pressure sintered composites.
It can be seen that the ceramic fillers show a homogeneous distribution over a wide
range of microstructure without large aggregation.
Fig 8 shows the thermal conductivity of the Cu-AlN composites and the monolithic copper
plate. The measured thermal conductivity of the Cu plate sample at 50°C was 447 W/m·K.
The thermal conductivity of the composite containing 10 wt% of AlN filler prepared
by sintering at atmospheric pressure was 134 W/m·K. In case of 30 wt% of AlN sample
sintered at atmospheric pressure showed a thermal conductivity of 172 W/m·K. The low
thermal conductivity is ascribed to the many pores present after atmospheric pressure
sintering, as shown in the microstructure image in Fig 4(a) and 4(b).
Assuming there were no pores in the Cu-AlN composite, the theoretical thermal conductivity
can be calculated using the rule of mixture.
αe = αmVm +αfVf
Here, αe is the calculated thermal conductivity of the composite, αm is the thermal conductivity of the single phase Cu, about 400 W/m·K, Vm is the volume fraction of Cu, αf is the thermal conductivity of AlN used as filler, about 280 W/m·K, and Vf is the volume fraction of AIN. The calculated thermal conductivity for the composite
with 10 wt% AlN filler was 360 W/m·K. The difference between the measured and calculated
values is attributed to the presence of pores in the sintered body and the lattice
diffusion of oxygen impurities during the sintering process. A. L. Loeb [23] reported that materials with good thermal conductivity displayed rapid heat transfer
in one direction, however if pores were present, the heat flow was cut off or flowed
in the other direction, adversely affecting thermal conductivity. In case of the hot-pressed
sample, which exhibited a denser microstructure (Fig 5(a)), the measured thermal conductivity was improved (290 W/m·K at at 50 °C) even though
the AlN filler content was increased to 30 wt%. This means that the amount of pores
has a greater effect on thermal conductivity than the filler content.
Fig 9 shows the measured thermal conductivity of the atmospheric pressure sintered Cu/SiC
composites. Assuming a fully densified Cu and SiC composite that excludes the presence
of pores, the thermal conductivity of the composite according to the mixing ratio
of SiC was calculated using the rule of mixture. The thermal conductivity was calculated
as 382 W/m·K at 10 wt% SiC filler, 356 W/m·K at 15 wt% SiC filler, and 333 W/m·K at
20 wt% SiC filler. There was a significant difference between the calculated thermal
conductivity and the actual measured value. It is considered that this difference
is also caused by a large number of pores resulting from less densification of the
Cu composite as the amount of SiC filler content increase.
Fig 10 shows the thermal expansion behavior of the pure Cu plate and Cu/ceramic composites.
Furthermore, Table 1 shows the thermal expansion coefficient at 200 °C calculated by the rule of mixture
and the average value of the thermal expansion coefficient between 200 °C~600 °C calculated
based on actual graph of the thermal expansion behavior. The thermal expansion coefficient
of the pure Cu plate calculated from the graph was 16.3 × 10-6/°C, but it decreased to 13.3 × 10-6/°C when 10 wt% AlN filler was added. The thermal expansion coefficient decreased
to 9.2 × 10-6/°C when the AlN filler was increased to 30 wt% and the composite was subjected to
pressure sintering. The thermal expansion coefficient of the composite tended to decrease
as the ceramic filler content increased, when adding a ceramic filler with a low thermal
expansion coefficient. Furthermore, there was no significant difference between the
thermal expansion coefficient calculated using the rule of mixture and the measured
average thermal expansion coefficient [10]. In the composite, the thermal expansion coefficient is affected by various factors
such as adhesion at the interface, dispersion of the filler, filler shape etc. However,
it was found that the presence of pores did not significantly affect the thermal expansion
coefficient in contrast to the thermal conductivity.
4. Conclusions
A Cu matrix-ceramic filler composite, with a homogeneous microstructure, was fabricated
using a polymer solution synthesis method, and the physical properties were examined
with different ceramic filler content and sintering methods. As the filler content
increased, the densification was hindered, and more pores were observed. These pores
had a significant influence, lowering the thermal conductivity. A dense composite
with reduced pores could be obtained by hot press sintering. The densified composite
finally showed a thermal conductivity of 290 W/m·K and a thermal expansion coefficient
of 9.2 × 10-6/°C, when 30wt% AlN filler was added.
By adding a suitable ceramic filler to Cu and densifying it, it was possible to manufacture
a new heat dissipation material with a lowers thermal expansion coefficient without
significantly reducing the excellent thermal conductivity of Cu.